The final word on the Modculture forums

by Modculture 11 April, 2012

Modculture

Modculture

Just a quick piece about the Modculture forums, not least because there have been a few comments about it posted here and there (some less than pleasant). This is the final word.

The forums were closed down last year, effectively because they ‘broke’. I spent a lot of time trying to sort out the problems with the forum (including one sleepless night), but it was impossible. With that in mind, I closed them down and deleted them.

At the same time, I realised that the entire Modculture site was showing its age and needed to start again. After many months work, a new site went live a month or so back, the first step in a new way of doing things. It was a lot of work to create a new site and it’s still not complete. But we’re a few steps up the hill.

When we talked about doing a new site, the important thing was to make it interactive, make it easy to update and make it easy to use. Hopefully that’s in place – if you want anything listing and featuring, you’re just an email away from getting it listed. You can also comment and discuss away on the site too.

The forums were always going to be sorted later down the line – if at all. The problem with a forum is that it involves a lot more work than you might imagine.

Everyday is spent knocking back the people who want to join for all the wrong reasons, all posts have to be monitored and if ‘disagreements’ break out, someone has to sort it out. That means constant monitoring…and time given over to it.

When the forums closed, we had just two people willing to moderate (on top of myself) – it wasn’t a job anyone wanted. On top of that, the number of people using the forums had dropped off and the vast majority of posts were plugs and sales pitches, rather than genuine discussion. In short, the forum wasn’t in fine health, no matter what pair of rose-coloured specs you might be wearing.

People who know me personally will know I’m also very busy both with work (this isn’t my job) and in my personal life. I haven’t got time to manage a public forum anymore. Not only that, I don’t particularly want to play ‘teacher’ with the small amount of spare time I have – and on past evidence, neither would many other people. The time I have, I spend updating the new site.

But that’s not the end of the story. When the new site is finally up to date and when I get more time, I am looking at starting a forum of sorts. It will not be a public forum, it will possibly be invite-only and it’s likely to be hosted away from the main site. Basically, you sign up to be involved, not just to peak over the fence and occasionally plug.

I can’t say when that will be, but I’ll probably use the social networks and/or the newsletter to let people know. But for now, as I said, that is the final word on the forums. In the meantime, if you want anything listing, get in touch with the site and that should happen.

  • Lord_Mulberry

    Hi all. Personally I think a forum is a must. I don’t come here as often without a forum because there doesn’t seem much point. By that I mean the site seems to change very little so I drop in maybe once a fortnight. If the forum was up I’d be here numerous times a day. I understand it’s a lot of work to manage so maybe just have one of two forums? I think there was too many forums before to be honest. Maybe a forum for clothes and one for events (music and scootering) and that’s it. Thoughts?

    • To be honest, events can be listed on the calendar and all can be commented on, so not really much point in having an events forum – at least 5 new events have gone up this week alone. More to come too. This is perhaps the first week I’ve been free to update the site since it relaunched.

      As I said above, no time to watch any kind of forums, life is too busy, maybe in the future that will change. But any new forum certainly wouldn’t be a public one.

  • JP

    Congrats on the new site launch. Looking good!

  • JTAitch

    Probably for the best after some of the handbags on there.